Archive for the ‘Military History’ Category

Wednesday, February 23rd, 2011 at 8:39am

Libya Highlights Obama’s Foreign Policy Confusion

There are few things more important to a statesman than credibility and consistency when it comes to administering a nation’s foreign policy.  The Obama administration’s response to recent events in Egypt and Libya underscore its foreign policy confusion.  The White House has a peculiar habit of treating allied governments and adversarial governments as equals.  This stems from President Barack Obama’s professed belief that all nations are indeed equal in Washington’s eyes.  Of course, the reality of international politics is quite the opposite.  More than two-thousand years of human history support this fact.   Some states, whose national interests overlap and intersect, join together as allies.  States whose national interests collide tend to have more adversarial relationships.

Understanding the role alliance systems play…

Thursday, October 21st, 2010 at 10:11am

Will Colin Powell be the Next Secretary of Defense?

An interesting post by Jason Sigger at Armchair Generalist got me thinking about who will be the next Secretary of Defense, as Secretary Gates’s tenure begins to wind down.  It’s widely believed that he will step down sometime in early to mid-2011.  Personally, I think President Obama will get some serious backlash if he selects General Powell to replace Secretary Gates.  I think there’s already a feeling within Democratic national security circles that he shouldn’t have asked Gates to remain in the position in the first place, that he should have selected a Democrat. Sigger isn’t a fan of Powell for the job, writing that,

…the February 2003 speech to the United Nations, featuring the faux vial of anthrax, still sits out there….

Tuesday, September 28th, 2010 at 8:22pm

Pledge to America Light on Foreign Policy Thinking

An interesting critique from liberal blogger Max Bergmann of the GOP’s Pledge to America which conspicuously fails to address, in any substantive terms, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

This isn’t a national security election. But the United States still has more than 100,000 troops engaged in combat in two different countries. You would think that if you were the opposition party laying out your plan for American that would be worth a mention, no?

In the 45 page “Pledge to America,” subtitled “a new governing agenda built on the priorities of our nation,” the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq apparently don’t amount to a GOP priority worth mentioning…

…There are platitudes of course. It notes “we are a nation at…

Wednesday, June 23rd, 2010 at 1:45pm

Breaking News: Obama Accepts McChrystal’s Resignation, Petraeus Named as Replacement

It’s not too surprising that this is how it ended up.  Obama, who is already perceived as a weak and indecisive leader by many, would have lost pretty much all credibility as a serious leader had he not relieved McChrystal.  Gen. David Petraeus is currently the Commander of U.S. Central Command (CENTCOM) and oversees the military campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan.  So this is a bit of a peculiar arrangement.

A friend just e-mailed me with the following comment, “one 2012 rival out of the way…”

Tuesday, June 8th, 2010 at 10:00am

The Worst Journalist in American History?

Posted by Tom Skypek in American Foreign Policy, Military History

No, I’m not talking about Helen Thomas.  Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Tom Ricks, who blogs at ForeignPolicy.com, recently identified General Douglas MacArthur as the worst general in American history.  This is quite a charge, considering that Ricks offers only a half-hearted, incomplete argument.  I think that a man who served his country for more than half a century deserves more respect–or a coherent argument, at the very least.  The real kicker is that Benedict Arnold, according to Ricks, was a better general than MacArthur.  Now I’m not sure what his metrics were for evaluating these officers–maybe their strategic, operational, and tactical acumen, I don’t know.  Clearly, loyalty to one’s country was not a criterion.  To put a traitor like…

© 2010 Hope is Not a Foreign Policy: Conservative commentary on foreign policy, American politics, and current events